Insurance Denials: A Comprehensive Review and Navigating the Peer Review Process

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

5-15-2026

Publication Title

The Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons

Keywords

Humans, United States, Health Care Costs, Prior Authorization, Peer Review, Value-Based Health Care, Insurance Claim Review

Abstract

Insurance companies and third-party reviewers use the peer review process including prior authorization (PA) and the peer-to-peer (P2P) process to manage healthcare costs and ensure appropriate care, citing principles of value-based care. As the volume of initial denials increases, physicians face notable time burdens and increased administrative costs while patients can incur delays and possibly worse health outcomes. We aim to explore the legal and ethical framework of utilization management; examine the effect on treating physicians, patients, and reviewers; offer suggestions for navigating peer-to-peer reviews; and propose future directions and improvement opportunities.

Medical Subject Headings

Humans; United States; Health Care Costs; Prior Authorization; Peer Review; Value-Based Health Care; Insurance Claim Review

PubMed ID

42065609

Volume

34

Issue

10

First Page

1368

Share

COinS